A percolator pumps boiling water up a central tube and showers it over the coffee, then lets it drain back into the pot — repeatedly.
The fundamental problem
Coffee that has already been brewed is brewed again, and again. Each cycle extracts more, well past the point where anything good is left.
That is why percolator coffee has a reputation for bitterness, and the reputation is earned.
Making it drinkable
Coarse grind. Coarser than a French press. Fine grounds over-extract instantly under this treatment and slip through the basket.
Low heat once it starts perking. You want a gentle cycle, not a rolling boil. Listen for the rhythm and turn the heat down as soon as you hear it.
Time it. Five to eight minutes from the first perk. Longer is not stronger, it is more bitter.
Take it off and serve immediately. Coffee left on the heat keeps cycling.
Why people keep them
Ruggedness. A percolator has no paper, no plastic, no electronics and no moving parts. For camping, boats and power cuts it is genuinely useful, and it makes coffee for eight.
The taste
Heavy, strong, low in acidity, with none of the clarity of a filter brew. Done well it is honest and comforting.